Pro-Con Page

For this topic, I was required to research both sides of the argument, those for it, and those against it.  After my research, I wrote two essays.  In the essay for the snake ban, the primary argument is the fact that careless snake owners and inexperienced personnel are taking in these massive animals, only to release them, in turn destroying the natural ecosystem.  Also, the argument states that the snakes pose a threat to humans, and many people have been killed or harmed by these large snakes that are not native to the United States.  In the argument against the snake ban, people state that it is an unfair punishment for responsible snake owners and breeders that are not contributing to the problem in Florida.  They also state that the damage to the ecosystem is done, and banning the importation of snakes now will help nothing.

After researching both sides of the argument, I agree with the snake ban.  Due to the danger the snakes cause, and the damage being done to the ecosystem, I believe it is in the best interest of the Florida residents and ecosystem to continue the snake ban.  The following is the essay I wrote arguing for the Florida Snake ban:

For Florida Snake Ban
            The state of Florida is experiencing a serious problem in the form of snake infestation.  Yes, you heard me correctly, snakes, and lots of them.  The Florida Everglades has become overpopulated with large constrictor snakes that are eating everything in sight, and monopolizing the ecosystem.  Not only are they scary to look at, but they are virtually destroying an ecosystem.  In fact These snakes are responsible for a 99.7% decline in everglades mammals, and over 300 attacks on humans (Puckett).  There are currently tens of thousands of snakes living in the Florida Everglades.  Clearly seeing this as a serious problem, the state of Florida has decided to implement a ban on the import of four exotic snake species including the Burmese python (the Everglades main culprit), the northern and southern African python, and the yellow anaconda.  All are exotic constrictor snakes that range in size of twelve to twenty two feet.  Exotic snake owners and breeders are outraged, claiming it is not fair to implement a ban for them when it was a few neglectful owners that are to blame for the snake problem.  It is a wise idea to ban the importing of these snakes because it will prevent any increase in population of these snakes, it will protect humans from these dangerous animals, and it will help rebuild the Everglades ecosystem.
            Banning the import of these snakes should help reduce the population in the everglades, and that is very important.  As mentioned before, there are tens of thousands of these deadly reptiles currently living in the Everglades.  However, there are supposed to be zero here naturally.  Researchers and wildlife commission officials state that the pythons arrived in the Everglades from many neglectful snake owners that released the snakes into the wild, thinking it would be a humane way to dispose of them since they became too big to handle.  A Fox News journalist states, “Teenagers and young adults think these snakes are cool when they are two feet long, but when they become 12 feet long, people get scared and throw them into the wild” (Chiaramonte).  Now that these snakes are in the wild, with others to breed with, their numbers can continue to grow.  The snake ban will prevent this “neglectful owner” problem from happening again because it makes it impossible for inexperienced snake owners to purchase these monsters as pets.  In addition to the prevention of further snake introduction to the wild, it also puts a hold on where the population stands.  With no more snakes entering the state, it allows the wildlife commission to try and eradicate the problem without the risk of other snakes entering into the equation.  Addressing the issue of angry exotic snake experts, the state of Florida is allowing current snake owners to keep their pets, and even breed them as long as they do not transport the snakes over state lines.  This means that the experienced snake owners can continue to enjoy their passion without posing a risk to other states by carrying the animals across state lines. 
            Not only will the snake ban prevent pythons from further population, but it also protects humans, whom the snakes pose a very serious threat to.  According to Florida Humane Society Reports, in the year 2012 alone, there were over 300 constrictor snake attacks resulting in serious injury or death (“Attack”).  Also, this ban protects innocent people from others’ snakes.  For example in 2012 a 100 pound snake escaped from captivity and strangled and killed a 2 month old girl in the middle of the night.  This is simply unacceptable, and the snake ban will prevent these incidents from happening in the future.  In addition to snake attacks, these snakes are making their way north, posing a serious threat to all residents of Florida.  In fact, removal reports indicate that 3 Pythons have had to be removed from the city of Kendal, which is a staggering 19 miles from the Everglades.  This means that the snakes will stop at nothing to expand their population in the state, causing serious concern for all Florida residents.  These snakes presence in Florida also deters people from choosing it as a vacation spot.  With this ban, it will allow wildlife officials to get the python situation under control, hopefully attracting more vacationers, thus boosting south Florida’s economy.
            As mentioned before, the snakes of south Florida are taking a toll on the ecosystem of the Everglades.  With snake numbers at an all-time high, and with no end in sight, the pythons will continue to destroy the ecosystem, unless something is done.  The Florida snake ban will prevent other snakes from entering, in turn preventing more snakes from eating the other (now endangered) animals, and overpopulating the ecosystem.  In addition to the physical effects the snakes have on Florida, they are also causing economic troubles.  The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has spent more than six million dollars in an effort to remove these snakes and control the population (Oberhofer 22).
            In conclusion, it is safe to say that these snakes are ruining south Florida, and there is only one way to stop this from getting worse: the Florida snake ban.  Without a snake ban, we would see the problems get worse, here about more tragic attack stories, and watch as the pythons start to take over the state.  Although the ban angers a few, it is best to regulate and control snake imports to benefit the large majority of the population.



Works Cited
 Florida Nature Conserve. Florida Fish and Wildlife Commision, 30 Dec. 2012. Web. 1 Nov. 2013.
 Fox News. Fox, 24 May 2013. Web. 31 Oct. 2013.
Oberhofer, Lori. "The Economic Cost of Large Constrictor Snakes." FWS (2012): 22. Print.
Puckett, Catherine. "Severe Decline in Everglades Mammals Linked to Pythons." USGS. U.S. Geological Survey, 30 Jan. 2012. Web. 2 Nov. 2013.
 

No comments:

Post a Comment